Fixed api issue

Reviewed-on: #11

app/Http/Controllers/api/BylawApiController.php

@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@ use App\Models\BylawNode;
 use App\Models\BylawCodificationLink;
 use App\Traits\BaseApiResponse;
 use Illuminate\Http\Request;
+use Illuminate\Support\Facades\DB;
 
 class BylawApiController extends Controller
 {
@@ -51,7 +52,7 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
             'per_page'              => 'nullable|integer|min:1|max:100',
         ]);
 
-        $query = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+        $query = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
             ->where('is_published', true);
 
         if ($request->filled('category_id')) {
@@ -96,7 +97,7 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
 
     public function single($id)
     {
-        $bylaw = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+        $bylaw = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
             ->where('is_published', true)
             ->find($id);
 
@@ -160,7 +161,7 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
             'per_page' => 'nullable|integer|min:1|max:100',
         ]);
 
-        $query = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+        $query = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
             ->where('is_published', true);
 
         if ($request->filled('search')) {
@@ -171,8 +172,10 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
                     ->orWhere('description', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
                     ->orWhere('promulgation_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
                     ->orWhere('official_gazette_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                    ->orWhereHas('nodes', function ($nodeQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    ->orWhereIn('id', function($subQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
-                        $nodeQuery->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                        $subQuery->select('document_id')
+                            ->from('bylaw_nodes')
+                            ->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
                     });
             });
         }
@@ -209,7 +212,7 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
     {
         $searchTerm = $request->input('search');
 
-        $query = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+        $query = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
             ->where('is_published', true);
 
         if (!empty($searchTerm)) {
@@ -218,8 +221,10 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
                     ->orWhere('description', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
                     ->orWhere('promulgation_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
                     ->orWhere('official_gazette_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                    ->orWhereHas('nodes', function ($nodeQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    ->orWhereIn('id', function($subQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
-                        $nodeQuery->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                        $subQuery->select('document_id')
+                            ->from('bylaw_nodes')
+                            ->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
                     });
             });
         }
@@ -237,7 +242,7 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
 
     public function pager($id)
     {
-        $current = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+        $current = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
             ->where('is_published', true)
             ->find($id);
 
@@ -248,7 +253,7 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
             ], 404);
         }
 
-        $previousItem = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+        $previousItem = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
             ->where('is_published', true)
             ->where(function ($query) use ($current) {
                 if ($current->approval_date) {
@@ -265,7 +270,7 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
             ->orderBy('id', 'desc')
             ->first();
 
-        $nextItem = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+        $nextItem = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
             ->where('is_published', true)
             ->where(function ($query) use ($current) {
                 if ($current->approval_date) {
@@ -303,10 +308,20 @@ class BylawApiController extends Controller
     {
         $isLocked = $this->isLockedForCurrentUser($item);
 
-        // Map description: If description is null, combine all node_content into one full text!
         $description = $item->description;
-        if (empty($description) && $item->relationLoaded('nodes')) {
+
-            $description = $item->nodes->pluck('node_content')->filter()->implode("\n\n");
+        // Check if description is practically empty (null, empty string, or just empty WYSIWYG HTML like <p></p>)
+        $cleanDesc = trim(strip_tags($description ?? ''));
+
+        // Direct Query Fallback: Fetch node_content manually via DB facade to bypass any Model restrictions
+        if (empty($cleanDesc)) {
+            $nodeContents = DB::table('bylaw_nodes')
+                ->where('document_id', $item->id)
+                ->orderBy('sort_order', 'asc')
+                ->pluck('node_content')
+                ->toArray();
+
+            $description = implode("\n\n", array_filter($nodeContents));
         }
 
         return [

app/Http/Controllers/api/GlobalSearchApiController.php

@@ -19,13 +19,14 @@ use App\Models\Volum;
 use App\Traits\BaseApiResponse;
 use Illuminate\Http\Request;
 use Illuminate\Pagination\LengthAwarePaginator;
+use Illuminate\Support\Facades\DB;
 
 class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
 {
     use BaseApiResponse;
 
     /**
-     * Massive Search across ALL data types (With dynamic Date/Number Sorting)
+     * Massive Search across ALL data types
      */
     public function search(Request $request)
     {
@@ -41,68 +42,30 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
         $perPage = min(max((int) $request->input('per_page', 15), 10), 100);
         $page = (int) $request->input('page', 1);
 
-        $results = collect();
+        $staticResults = collect();   // Arts and Structures (Always at the top)
+        $sortableResults = collect(); // Bylaws, Opinions, Precedents (Sorted if requested)
 
         if (!empty($searchTerm)) {
-            $limitPerTable = 100; // Performance safeguard
+            $limitPerTable = 100;
 
-            // 1. Search Bylaw Documents (Including deeper node_content search)
+            // =========================================================
-            $bylaws = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+            // 1. Search Arts (Exact match to ArtController)
-                ->where('is_published', true)
+            // =========================================================
+            $arts = Art::with(['law.category', 'chapter', 'part', 'volum', 'book', 'section', 'gate'])
                 ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
                     $q->where('title', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('description', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                        ->orWhere('promulgation_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                })
-                        ->orWhere('official_gazette_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhereHas('nodes', function ($nodeQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
-                            $nodeQuery->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                        });
-                })->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
-                    $formatted = $this->formatBylaw($item);
-                    $formatted['type'] = 'bylaw';
-                    return $formatted;
-                });
-            $results = $results->merge($bylaws);
-
-            // 2. Search Judicial Precedents
-            $judicials = JudicialPrecedent::with('category')
-                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
-                    $q->where('ruling_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                })->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
-                    $formatted = $this->formatJudicial($item);
-                    $formatted['type'] = 'judicial_precedent';
-                    return $formatted;
-                });
-            $results = $results->merge($judicials);
-
-            // 3. Search Legal Opinions
-            $opinions = LegalOpinion::with('category')
-                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
-                    $q->where('opinion_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('issuing_authority', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                })->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
-                    $formatted = $this->formatOpinion($item);
-                    $formatted['type'] = 'legal_opinion';
-                    return $formatted;
-                });
-            $results = $results->merge($opinions);
-
-            // 4. Search Arts
-            $arts = Art::with(['law.category'])
-                ->where('title', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                ->orWhere('text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
                 ->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) use ($searchTerm) {
                     $formatted = $this->formatArt($item, $searchTerm, Art::class);
                     $formatted['type'] = 'art';
                     return $formatted;
                 });
-            $results = $results->merge($arts);
+            $staticResults = $staticResults->concat($arts);
 
-            // 5. Search Laws and Structural Models
+            // =========================================================
+            // 2. Search Laws and Structural Models (Exact match to ArtController)
+            // =========================================================
             $structuralModels = [
                 Law::class, Volum::class, Book::class, Division::class,
                 Section::class, Chapter::class, Part::class, Gate::class,
@@ -122,39 +85,95 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
                     return $formatted;
                 });
 
-                $results = $results->merge($items);
+                $staticResults = $staticResults->concat($items);
             }
+
+            // =========================================================
+            // 3. Search Bylaw Documents
+            // =========================================================
+            $bylaws = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
+                ->where('is_published', true)
+                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    $q->where('title', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('description', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('promulgation_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('official_gazette_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhereIn('id', function($subQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
+                            $subQuery->select('document_id')
+                                ->from('bylaw_nodes')
+                                ->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                        });
+                })->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
+                    $formatted = $this->formatBylaw($item);
+                    $formatted['type'] = 'bylaw';
+                    return $formatted;
+                });
+            $sortableResults = $sortableResults->concat($bylaws);
+
+            // =========================================================
+            // 4. Search Judicial Precedents
+            // =========================================================
+            $judicials = JudicialPrecedent::with('category')
+                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    $q->where('ruling_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                })->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
+                    $formatted = $this->formatJudicial($item);
+                    $formatted['type'] = 'judicial_precedent';
+                    return $formatted;
+                });
+            $sortableResults = $sortableResults->concat($judicials);
+
+            // =========================================================
+            // 5. Search Legal Opinions
+            // =========================================================
+            $opinions = LegalOpinion::with('category')
+                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    $q->where('opinion_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('issuing_authority', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                })->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
+                    $formatted = $this->formatOpinion($item);
+                    $formatted['type'] = 'legal_opinion';
+                    return $formatted;
+                });
+            $sortableResults = $sortableResults->concat($opinions);
         }
 
-        // --- Apply Dynamic Memory Sorting ---
+        // --- Apply Dynamic Memory Sorting ONLY to Legal Docs ---
-        if ($request->has('sort_by')) {
+        if ($request->has('sort_by') && $request->input('sort_by') != null) {
             $sortBy = $request->input('sort_by');
             $sortOrder = $request->input('sort', 'desc');
 
             if ($sortBy === 'number') {
                 $sortCallback = function ($item) {
-                    return (string) ($item['promulgation_number'] ?? $item['ruling_number'] ?? $item['opinion_number'] ?? $item['number'] ?? '');
+                    return (string) ($item['promulgation_number'] ?? $item['ruling_number'] ?? $item['opinion_number'] ?? '0');
                 };
 
                 if ($sortOrder === 'asc') {
-                    $results = $results->sortBy($sortCallback, SORT_NATURAL)->values();
+                    $sortableResults = $sortableResults->sortBy($sortCallback, SORT_NATURAL)->values();
                 } else {
-                    $results = $results->sortByDesc($sortCallback, SORT_NATURAL)->values();
+                    $sortableResults = $sortableResults->sortByDesc($sortCallback, SORT_NATURAL)->values();
                 }
             } elseif ($sortBy === 'date') {
                 $sortCallback = function ($item) {
-                    return (string) ($item['approval_date'] ?? $item['ruling_date'] ?? $item['opinion_date'] ?? '');
+                    return (string) ($item['approval_date'] ?? $item['ruling_date'] ?? $item['opinion_date'] ?? '1970-01-01');
                 };
 
                 if ($sortOrder === 'asc') {
-                    $results = $results->sortBy($sortCallback)->values();
+                    $sortableResults = $sortableResults->sortBy($sortCallback)->values();
                 } else {
-                    $results = $results->sortByDesc($sortCallback)->values();
+                    $sortableResults = $sortableResults->sortByDesc($sortCallback)->values();
                 }
             }
         }
 
-        // --- Execute Manual Pagination on the Sorted Collection ---
+        // Combine Results: Arts and Structures ALWAYS pin to the top!
+        $results = $staticResults->concat($sortableResults);
+
+        // --- Execute Manual Pagination on the final Collection ---
         $total = $results->count();
         $paginatedItems = $results->forPage($page, $perPage)->values();
 
@@ -174,7 +193,7 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
             'total'        => $paginator->total(),
         ];
 
-        return $this->success($responseData, 'Success', 'Global Search Results Fetched');
+        return $this->success($responseData, '', '');
     }
 
     /**
@@ -190,70 +209,21 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
 
         if (!empty($searchTerm)) {
 
-            // 1. Bylaw Documents
+            // 1. Search Arts FIRST
-            $bylawQuery = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority', 'nodes'])
+            $artQuery = Art::with(['law', 'law.category', 'chapter', 'part', 'volum', 'book', 'section', 'gate'])
-                ->where('is_published', true)
                 ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
                     $q->where('title', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('description', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                        ->orWhere('promulgation_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('official_gazette_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhereHas('nodes', function ($nodeQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
-                            $nodeQuery->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                        });
                 });
-            $totalCount += $bylawQuery->count();
-            $bylaws = $bylawQuery->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
-                $formatted = $this->formatBylaw($item);
-                $formatted['type'] = 'bylaw';
-                return $formatted;
-            });
-            $results = $results->merge($bylaws);
-
-            // 2. Judicial Precedents
-            $judicialQuery = JudicialPrecedent::with('category')
-                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
-                    $q->where('ruling_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                });
-            $totalCount += $judicialQuery->count();
-            $judicials = $judicialQuery->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
-                $formatted = $this->formatJudicial($item);
-                $formatted['type'] = 'judicial_precedent';
-                return $formatted;
-            });
-            $results = $results->merge($judicials);
-
-            // 3. Legal Opinions
-            $opinionQuery = LegalOpinion::with('category')
-                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
-                    $q->where('opinion_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                        ->orWhere('issuing_authority', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
-                });
-            $totalCount += $opinionQuery->count();
-            $opinions = $opinionQuery->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
-                $formatted = $this->formatOpinion($item);
-                $formatted['type'] = 'legal_opinion';
-                return $formatted;
-            });
-            $results = $results->merge($opinions);
-
-            // 4. Search Arts
-            $artQuery = Art::with(['law.category'])
-                ->where('title', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
-                ->orWhere('text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
             $totalCount += $artQuery->count();
             $arts = $artQuery->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) use ($searchTerm) {
                 $formatted = $this->formatArt($item, $searchTerm, Art::class);
                 $formatted['type'] = 'art';
                 return $formatted;
             });
-            $results = $results->merge($arts);
+            $results = $results->concat($arts);
 
-            // 5. Structural Models
+            // 2. Structural Models
             $structuralModels = [
                 Law::class, Volum::class, Book::class, Division::class,
                 Section::class, Chapter::class, Part::class, Gate::class,
@@ -275,15 +245,68 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
                         $formatted['type'] = ($table === 'section') ? 'sections' : $table;
                         return $formatted;
                     });
-                    $results = $results->merge($items);
+                    $results = $results->concat($items);
                 }
             }
+
+            // 3. Bylaw Documents
+            $bylawQuery = BylawDocument::with(['category', 'approvalAuthority', 'promulgationAuthority'])
+                ->where('is_published', true)
+                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    $q->where('title', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('description', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('promulgation_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('official_gazette_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhereIn('id', function($subQuery) use ($searchTerm) {
+                            $subQuery->select('document_id')
+                                ->from('bylaw_nodes')
+                                ->where('node_content', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                        });
+                });
+            $totalCount += $bylawQuery->count();
+            $bylaws = $bylawQuery->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
+                $formatted = $this->formatBylaw($item);
+                $formatted['type'] = 'bylaw';
+                return $formatted;
+            });
+            $results = $results->concat($bylaws);
+
+            // 4. Judicial Precedents
+            $judicialQuery = JudicialPrecedent::with('category')
+                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    $q->where('ruling_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                });
+            $totalCount += $judicialQuery->count();
+            $judicials = $judicialQuery->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
+                $formatted = $this->formatJudicial($item);
+                $formatted['type'] = 'judicial_precedent';
+                return $formatted;
+            });
+            $results = $results->concat($judicials);
+
+            // 5. Legal Opinions
+            $opinionQuery = LegalOpinion::with('category')
+                ->where(function ($q) use ($searchTerm) {
+                    $q->where('opinion_number', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('subject', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('full_text', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%")
+                        ->orWhere('issuing_authority', 'LIKE', "%{$searchTerm}%");
+                });
+            $totalCount += $opinionQuery->count();
+            $opinions = $opinionQuery->take($limitPerTable)->get()->map(function($item) {
+                $formatted = $this->formatOpinion($item);
+                $formatted['type'] = 'legal_opinion';
+                return $formatted;
+            });
+            $results = $results->concat($opinions);
         }
 
         return $this->success([
             'items' => $results->take(15)->values(),
             'count' => $totalCount
-        ], 'Success', 'Global Fast Search Results');
+        ], '', '');
     }
 
     /* -----------------------------------------------------------------
@@ -298,11 +321,18 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
     private function formatBylaw($item)
     {
         $isLocked = $this->isLockedForCurrentUserGeneric($item);
-
-        // Fallback description to node_content if empty
         $description = $item->description;
-        if (empty($description) && $item->relationLoaded('nodes')) {
+
-            $description = $item->nodes->pluck('node_content')->filter()->implode("\n\n");
+        $cleanDesc = trim(strip_tags($description ?? ''));
+
+        if (empty($cleanDesc)) {
+            $nodeContents = DB::table('bylaw_nodes')
+                ->where('document_id', $item->id)
+                ->orderBy('sort_order', 'asc')
+                ->pluck('node_content')
+                ->toArray();
+
+            $description = implode("\n\n", array_filter($nodeContents));
         }
 
         return [
@@ -349,39 +379,44 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
         ];
     }
 
+    /**
+     * Exact 1:1 match with ArtController::searchModel mapping
+     * All relations (law, chapter, etc) are strictly Strings to prevent App Crashes!
+     */
     private function formatArt($item, $searchTerm, $modelClass)
     {
         $law = $item->law ?? Law::find($item->law_id);
-        $isLocked = ! auth()->user()->isSubscriber() && (bool) $law?->is_locked;
+        $isLocked = ! auth()->user()->isSubscriber() && (bool) ($law?->is_locked ?? false);
 
         $text = $item->text ?? '';
         $searchQuoted = preg_quote($searchTerm, '/');
-        if (!empty($text) && preg_match('/\b(.{0,50})\b('.$searchQuoted.')\b(.{0,50})\b/i', $text, $matches)) {
+        if (!empty($searchTerm) && preg_match('/\b(.{0,50})\b('.$searchQuoted.')\b(.{0,50})\b/i', $text, $matches)) {
-            $context = trim($matches[1] ?? '') . ' ' . $matches[2] . ' ' . trim($matches[3] ?? '');
+            $context = trim($matches[1] ?? '').' '.($matches[2] ?? '').' '.trim($matches[3] ?? '');
         } else {
             $context = $text;
         }
 
         return [
-            'id'          => $item->id,
+            'id'           => $item->id,
-            'title'       => $item->title,
+            'title'        => $item->title,
-            'number'      => $item->number,
+            'number'       => $item->number,
-            'text'        => $isLocked ? null : $context,
+            'text'         => $isLocked ? null : $context,
-            'is_locked'   => $isLocked,
+            'is_locked'    => $isLocked,
-            'route'       => array_values($this->route($modelClass, $item)),
+            'route'        => array_values($this->route($modelClass, $item)),
-            'category'    => optional($law->category)->name,
+            'category'     => optional($law?->category)->name,
-            'law'         => $law?->title,
+            'law'          => $law?->title ?? '', // STRICLY STRING! Prevents Android App Crash!
-            'count_art'   => $law?->arts?->count() ?? 0,
+            'count_art'    => $law?->arts?->count() ?? 0,
-            'count_volums'=> $law?->volums?->count() ?? 0,
+            'count_volums' => $law?->volums?->count() ?? 0, // WITH S
-            'price'       => $law?->price,
+            'count_volum'  => $law?->volums?->count() ?? 0, // WITHOUT S (Fallback)
-            'image'       => $law?->image,
+            'price'        => $law?->price,
+            'image'        => $law?->image,
         ];
     }
 
     private function formatStructure($item, $modelClass)
     {
         $law = Law::find($item?->law_id ?? $item->id);
-        $isLocked = ! auth()->user()->isSubscriber() && (bool) $law?->is_locked;
+        $isLocked = ! auth()->user()->isSubscriber() && (bool) ($law?->is_locked ?? false);
 
         $payload = [
             'id'        => $item->id,
@@ -389,7 +424,7 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
             'number'    => $item->number,
             'is_locked' => $isLocked,
             'route'     => array_values($this->route($modelClass, $item)),
-            'law'       => $law?->title ?? '',
+            'law'       => $law?->title ?? '', // STRICTLY STRING
         ];
 
         if ((new $modelClass)->getTable() == 'laws') {
@@ -404,14 +439,14 @@ class GlobalSearchApiController extends Controller
     {
         if ((new $modelClass)->getTable() == 'art') {
             $route = array_filter([
-                Law::find($query->law_id)?->title,
+                $query->relationLoaded('law') ? $query->law?->title : Law::find($query->law_id)?->title,
-                Volum::find($query->volum_id)?->title,
+                $query->relationLoaded('volum') ? $query->volum?->title : Volum::find($query->volum_id)?->title,
-                Book::find($query->book_id)?->title,
+                $query->relationLoaded('book') ? $query->book?->title : Book::find($query->book_id)?->title,
                 Division::find($query->division_id)?->title,
-                Section::find($query->section_id)?->title,
+                $query->relationLoaded('section') ? $query->section?->title : Section::find($query->section_id)?->title,
-                Chapter::find($query->chapter_id)?->title,
+                $query->relationLoaded('chapter') ? $query->chapter?->title : Chapter::find($query->chapter_id)?->title,
-                Part::find($query->part_id)?->title,
+                $query->relationLoaded('part') ? $query->part?->title : Part::find($query->part_id)?->title,
-                Gate::find($query->gate_id)?->title,
+                $query->relationLoaded('gate') ? $query->gate?->title : Gate::find($query->gate_id)?->title,
                 Branch::find($query->branch_id)?->title,
             ]);
             return array_values($route);